According to TD Cowen analyst Andrew Charles, Starbucks Inc. may encounter more significant challenges in China than investors have realized. Charles believes that China could become a burden on Starbucks' shares due to competitive pressures and the country's concerning macroeconomic climate.
In a recent downgrade, Charles lowered his rating on the company's stock from outperform to market perform, as well as reducing his price target from $117 to $107. As a result, the stock saw a 1.6% decline in morning trading on Tuesday.
Investor Anticipation and Concerns
Investors have been eagerly awaiting Starbucks' initial fiscal 2024 guidance, which is expected to be released alongside the next report. However, Charles expresses concern that Wall Street is becoming increasingly worried about the lack of visibility in the China landscape, potentially causing the company to refrain from issuing China same-store-sales guidance.
Competition and Market Share
Charles specifically points out the threat of competition from lower-cost players in China, including Luckin Coffee and Tim's China. These companies appear to be steadily capturing market share at the expense of Starbucks. Additionally, Cotti Coffee has ambitious growth plans in the region.
Navigating these challenges will be crucial for Starbucks as they strive to maintain their position in the Chinese market.
Starbucks in China: Challenges and Concerns
In recent years, Starbucks has been facing fierce competition in China's coffee shop market. While the company operates all its stores in the country, other players are leveraging the benefits of franchising to accelerate their expansion. This has prompted concerns about Starbucks' ability to maintain its market share and profitability.
One analyst, Charles, believes that aggressive deals and aggressive discounts offered by competitors will continue to pose a challenge for Starbucks in the medium term. Despite questions around the sustainability of these discounts, Charles expresses worries that competitors will benefit from economies of scale and declining coffee prices, further intensifying the pricing pressure.
Adding to the concerns, Charles also highlights various economic signals in China that raise skepticism about the effectiveness of government stimulus as a catalyst for growth.
In terms of same-store sales expectations, Charles is below the consensus view. He projects a growth of 10% in 2024 and 4.8% in 2025 for Starbucks in China. This is lower than what he sees as the consensus expectations of 10.5% and 5.4% growth, respectively.
While Starbucks continues to be a prominent player in the Chinese coffee market, these challenges and concerns indicate that the company needs to navigate a competitive landscape and economic uncertainties effectively to sustain its growth momentum.
Related: Howard Schultz steps down from Starbucks board of directors
Don't miss: Red flags waving for tech stocks as AI bounce fades, China fears escalate
PREVIOUS POST
